Southern Ireland (1920–1922): the legal entity created by partition
Southern Ireland was the 26‑county polity established on paper by the Government of Ireland Act 1920; it never formed a functioning government and was superseded by the Irish Free State after the Anglo‑Irish Treaty.
Southern Ireland was a legal creation of the United Kingdom enacted in 1920 as part of an attempt to reconcile competing Irish and British political claims. The arrangement, set out in the Government of Ireland Act 1920, divided the island into two separate jurisdictions: Northern Ireland in the northeast and Southern Ireland covering the remaining twenty‑six counties. The intention was to create two self‑governing parts of an Irish state within the United Kingdom, each with its own parliament and executive institutions.
Image gallery
1 Image
Planned structure and institutions
Under the 1920 measure, Southern Ireland was to have a bicameral parliamentary system consisting of an upper chamber (a Senate) and a lower chamber (House of Commons), plus a local government answerable to that parliament. The Crown retained a representative authority in the form of the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland, who was designated to carry out certain formal duties for both Northern and Southern Ireland. The law provided for separate administrations in each territory, mirroring the principle of devolution used elsewhere in the United Kingdom.
Why it never functioned as intended
Although the legal framework existed, Southern Ireland never developed a genuine, operative government. In the elections held under the Act many candidates associated with the Irish republican movement abstained from taking seats in the British‑established parliament, refusing to recognise the new institutions. The first convening of the Southern Ireland parliament failed to reach the quorum required to conduct business. A subsequent meeting served chiefly to record events related to the wider Irish political settlement — notably the ratification by Dáil Éireann of the Anglo‑Irish Treaty — and was soon dissolved. In practice, authority in much of the south passed to the Irish republican structures and then to the transitional bodies created by the Treaty.
Transition and legal end
The Anglo‑Irish Treaty of late 1921 provided for the establishment of the Irish Free State as a self‑governing dominion. That settlement, together with the practical political developments on the ground, rendered the statutory entity of Southern Ireland obsolete. The Irish Free State came into being in 1922, covering roughly the same territory intended for Southern Ireland (while Northern Ireland exercised its option to remain part of the United Kingdom). As a result, Southern Ireland existed mainly as a short‑lived legal category rather than as an effective polity.
Legacy and distinctions
Southern Ireland is important for understanding the constitutional transition from British rule to Irish self‑government in the early twentieth century. It should not be conflated with the later Irish Free State (1922–1937) or the modern Republic of Ireland. Southern Ireland was a transitional legal concept rooted in British parliamentary legislation; its failure to operate demonstrates how legal instruments can be overtaken by political legitimacy issues and negotiated settlements.
Key points
- Created by the Government of Ireland Act 1920 as one of two jurisdictions on the island.
- Designed to have a bicameral parliament and a locally responsible government under the Crown.
- Never formed an effective government because many elected representatives refused to participate; the parliament lacked a quorum.
- Superseded by the Irish Free State following the Anglo‑Irish Treaty; Northern Ireland remained separate.
History
The Government of Ireland Act, also known as the 4th Home Rule, was designed to find a solution to the problem that had plagued Irish politics since the 1880s: the dispute between unionists and nationalists. Nationalists had been seeking some form of Home Rule for decades, as they wanted to see Ireland without a British rule. Unionists, on the other hand, were afraid that a nationalist government in Dublin would act discriminatorily against Protestants and introduce taxes aimed mainly at the agricultural counties of the northeast. Extremist Unionists then imported early arms from the German Empire and formed the Ulster Volunteer Force to prevent the enforcement of Home Rule in Ulster. In turn, nationalists also imported arms and formed the Irish Volunteers in 1913. The final partition by the Government of Ireland Act was originally intended to be merely a transitional state.
In reality, however, Southern Ireland never became functioning - unlike Northern Ireland, where a working parliament was formed which lasted in this form until 1972. The first election to the Southern Ireland House of Commons in 1921 was seen by Sinn Féin as an election to the parliament of the revolutionary Irish Republic, which was unilaterally proclaimed in 1916 but never recognised. Sinn Féin won 124 out of 128 votes, but at the first meeting of the Southern Ireland Parliament in June 1921 only the four elected Unionists appeared (the elected Sinn Féin members assembled instead as a Second Dáil), so there could be no question of a Southern Ireland government.
It was not until January 1922 that the Southern Ireland House of Commons was given a supporting role. As British policy never recognised the revolutionary parliament, the Southern Irish House of Commons remained the only legal one in the eyes of the British. When the Anglo-Irish Treaty was created in 1921, the question arose as to which of the two powers of the state (the Southern Irish House of Commons or the revolutionary parliament of the Second Dáil) had to agree to this treaty from the Irish side. Since neither side wanted to give in, the treaty was ultimately recognised by both bodies (whose personnel composition was almost identical).
Southern Ireland was - in retrospect - only a separate state on paper, overshadowed by the revolutionary Irish Republic and absorbed into the Irish Free State as a result of the Anglo-Irish Treaty in December 1922. On the other hand, the co-negotiator of the Treaty and subsequent Chairman of the Provisional Government of Southern Ireland, Michael Collins, is regarded as an important figure in Irish Independence.
See also
Questions and answers
Q: What was Southern Ireland?
A: Southern Ireland was a twenty-six county Irish state created by the Government of Ireland Act 1920.
Q: How was Ireland divided after the Government of Ireland Act 1920?
A: The Government of Ireland Act 1920 divided Ireland into two parts, Northern Ireland and Southern Ireland.
Q: How much of Ireland did Northern Ireland cover?
A: Northern Ireland covered approximately fifteen percent of Ireland in the northeast.
Q: What kind of parliaments and governments were given to Northern and Southern Ireland?
A: Northern and Southern Ireland were given bicameral (two houses) parliaments and separate governments.
Q: Who represented the king in both Northern and Southern Ireland?
A: The Lord Lieutenant of Ireland represented the king in both Northern and Southern Ireland.
Q: Did Southern Ireland ever exist?
A: Southern Ireland never existed except on paper.
Q: Why did the attempted meeting of Southern Ireland's Parliament fail?
A: The first attempted meeting of Southern Ireland's Parliament failed because it was short of a quorum (the number of members needed to hold a meeting).
Related articles
Author
AlegsaOnline.com Southern Ireland (1920–1922): the legal entity created by partition Leandro Alegsa
URL: https://en.alegsaonline.com/art/92297