What is false dilemma?
Q: What is false dilemma?
A: False dilemma is a mistake in logic that presents only two options when more than two exist.
Q: What are some other names for false dilemma?
A: Some other names for false dilemma are either-or fallacy, us vs. them fallacy, black-or-white fallacy, false dichotomy, or the fallacy of false choice.
Q: What is an example of false dilemma?
A: An example of false dilemma is saying that an apple must be green or red, when some apples may also be yellow.
Q: Why is the premise of the apple example a mistake?
A: The premise of the apple example is a mistake because it assumes that the apple is either one color or the other, when in reality there may be other colors available.
Q: What is the purpose behind using a false dilemma?
A: The purpose behind using a false dilemma may be to eliminate agreement on an issue or to create comedic effect.
Q: Who used false dilemma as a tactic to eliminate agreement on an issue?
A: Eldridge Cleaver used false dilemma as a tactic to eliminate agreement on an issue when he said, "You're either part of the solution or part of the problem."
Q: Who used false dilemma for comedic effect?
A: Stephen Colbert used false dilemma for comedic effect when he asked guests on The Colbert Report, "George Bush... great president or the greatest president?"
